As always, I caught American Idol late last night. When I switched on the tv and tuned in to Star World, David A had already performed. Judging by his smiling face and the thunderous applause from the audience, I knew he had just received 3 thumbs ups (or 6) from the judges. Well, good for him considering how badly he performed last week – forgetting lyrics and all. He was lucky not to get kicked out. Other contestants who forgot their words were treated more harshly by the voters. They kicked them out (think Lindsay Cardinale and someone else).
Next, I think it was Michael (for some reason, I can never remember his last name – Johns? Yep, Johns), the Aussie, who sang. I’m not very familiar with all the Beatles’ songs so I’m not going to even try to tell you which song he sang. I thought it was an ok performance. The judges, however, seemed disappointed. I later read on Jennifer’s blog that one viewer thought that the judges were being too hard on him. Maybe. Well, I didn’t think he sucked but he wasn’t spectacular either.
Anyway, I can’t remember who performed next but all I remember thinking was last night was – based on the few contestants whom I saw, anyway – a night of mediocrity. I felt the show dragged on and on. And none of them made my heart sing the way Elliott Yamin did *gets all dreamy-eyed*
Anyway… I thought David C was getting more and more “smug”, as Simon put it. You’re a good performer, David, we already know that. So why don’t you give us something we don’t already know?
Syesha, I thought, sang off key. There was one part in the song where she hit a high note and I cringed. It was one of those well-concealed pitchy tone, so many people may not have noticed :P I have to hand it to her from trying “to do her own thing and be original” but she probably should have taken some notes from Boyz II Men who did a beautiful cover of Yesterday. Ok, granted they’re a group and they harmonised their vocals well for that song. BUT all I’m saying is that Syesha could learn something from them.
I still don’t get Carly. I still can’t connect to her — I think it’s funny how she tries to speak in an American accent but her Irish drawl is far too strong. I wonder what Simon thinks of this? — and I thought her red sleeveless top last night was hideous with a capital H. I’m going to sound really catty but I think Carly should consider toning her arms BEFORE she attempts to wear sleeveless tops. I don’t care if wearing sleeves will hide her tattoos. It’s not like she has to wear long-sleeved shirts or anything — actually, that’d be nice for a change :) — She just needs to cover her arms once in a while. Maybe she can try one of those asymmetrical tops. She should learn from Mel C of Spice Girls — a fellow tattoo lover — who said that her tats looked really good when she was slim and had shapely arms but once she gained weight, her tattoos looked yucky. I didn’t say it, Mel C did! So, remember Carly, tone before you bare! :)
I have no (good) opinion of Chikezie and Ramielle’s performances. I thought they were just mediocre. Ramielle is very lucky to still be in the competition after that ho hum performance last night. I’m sure she was better than Kristy Lee but she shouldn’t be performing as badly as Kristy Lee in the first place… coz Kristy Lee is… Kristy Lee… the girl who should’ve left the show a long time ago but hasn’t. I still think she (Ramielle) doesn’t have enough fan base to support her throughout this contest. She and Chikezie both.
Of course, Brooke White has enough fans to vote for her to go to the Top 3. But if she fails to shut up when the judges are giving her a less than satisfactory assessment, I won’t be surprised if they start leaving one by one. I mean, what was that — interrupting the judges — about? Boy, was she annoying! Well, now we know her Achilles heels — hers and Jason C’s. Without an instrument to hold and stool or step to sit on, she’s (they’re) nothing. She looked really awkward on stage without her usual props. So did Jason. Although I thought Jason’s performance was kinda cute :P But I was weirded out by how tight Jason’s jeans/pants were. I noticed this about him (or rather his pants) when he did Hallelujah a couple of weeks back. Give the guy some looser pants, already!
Anyway, did I forget to mention anyone else? I don’t think so. I’m not commenting on Amanda or Kristy Lee (or David A) because I didn’t see them sing.
Just so you know, by the time you read this, American viewers already know who’s out of the show. This week, it’s Amanda, the one trick pony rocker respiratory nurse. So long Amanda!
P/S: I can’t wait for the week when Mariah comes on the show as a mentor. Pressure much? Also, does this mean they have to sing her songs???? Or just the ones from the R&B, rap, hip hop genre? I can’t wait to see the Idol’s second rate Mariah “impersonations” :P I have a feeling Syesha or Ramielle (if both of them stay on the show long enough) will foolishly attempt to do a Mariah and fail. Hahaha *evil laugh*… I can’t wait!






